DNB COLLEGE

Drum & Bass Ableton Live 12 Tutorials

LESSON DETAIL

Concrete Echo approach: a darkside intro stretch in Ableton Live 12 (Intermediate)

An AI-generated intermediate Ableton lesson focused on Concrete Echo approach: a darkside intro stretch in Ableton Live 12 in the Atmospheres area of drum and bass production.

Back to lessons
Sign in with Google Full access enabled
Concrete Echo approach: a darkside intro stretch in Ableton Live 12 (Intermediate) cover image

Narrated lesson audio

The voice track includes the tutorial plus extra teacher commentary.

Open audio file

Main tutorial

Lesson Overview

This lesson is about building a Concrete Echo style intro stretch: a dark, concrete-like atmospheric opening that feels cold, spatial, and ominous, but still sits like a real Drum & Bass arrangement element rather than a random sound-design loop.

In a DnB track, this kind of intro usually lives in the first 8–16 bars before the full drums or bass arrive, or it acts as a DJ-friendly pre-drop tunnel that gives the next section more impact. It matters musically because it sets the world of the tune: the listener should feel pressure, distance, and movement before the groove fully lands. It matters technically because an intro like this has to be wide enough to feel cinematic, but controlled enough to leave room for the kick, snare, and sub when they enter.

This approach suits darkside, rollers, neuro-leaning, half-step tension, and more industrial DnB intros especially well. If your track needs to feel like it’s coming out of a concrete corridor, tunnel, warehouse stairwell, or abandoned rail yard, this is the lane.

By the end, you should be able to hear a stretch that feels like:

  • a brooding atmosphere with mechanical echoes
  • a rhythmic texture that implies motion without stealing the groove
  • a clear intro shape that can lead cleanly into a drop
  • a mix-ready opening that leaves low-end space and translates on club systems

    • A successful result should sound like the intro is breathing in the same world as the drums and bass, not floating separately above the track.

    What You Will Build

    You’ll build a dark, echo-driven intro bed using Ableton Live 12 stock tools: a short source sound, a filtered and distorted echo tail, a resampled texture layer, and a controlled arrangement shape that evolves over 8 or 16 bars.

    The finished result should have:

  • a cold, metallic, concrete tone
  • a pulsing, slightly unstable rhythmic feel
  • a supporting role that creates tension before the main DnB drums and bass
  • enough processing to feel polished, but not over-finished so it can still be adapted during the track build
  • clear separation between atmosphere and low-end elements, so the intro can survive a later drop transition

    • In normal terms: you want something that feels like a dark echo bouncing off a concrete wall in time with the tune, with enough movement to keep the ear engaged, but not so much that it becomes a wash.

    Step-by-Step Walkthrough

    1. Start with a dry source that has a hard edge, not a pretty pad

    In Ableton, create a new Audio track and drop in a short source sound: a metal hit, a found sound, a reverse reese stab, a scraped texture, or even a single transient from a drum loop. If you prefer synthesis, use Operator or Wavetable to make a short tonal ping with a fast attack and short decay.

    Keep it simple:

    - envelope decay around 150–500 ms

    - no long sustain

    - pitch area somewhere in the midrange, not sub territory

    - if using a sample, trim it so the front edge is tight

    Why this works in DnB: the intro needs a recognisable echo source that can be repeated or processed into space. A hard source reads well once delay and reverb start smearing it. A soft pad often turns into fog too quickly and doesn’t create the “concrete” character.

    What to listen for: the source should feel like it has a point of impact. Even before processing, it should suggest a wall, a strike, or a mechanical object rather than a musical chord wash.

    2. Shape the source with a narrow tonal footprint

    Before adding atmosphere, clean the source so it doesn’t compete with the low-end later. Use EQ Eight first.

    Good starting moves:

    - high-pass around 150–300 Hz depending on the source

    - if it feels boxy, dip around 250–500 Hz

    - if it has harsh metallic bite, tame 3–6 kHz with a small cut

    - if it needs more edge, add a controlled lift around 1.5–3 kHz

    This isn’t about making it pretty. It’s about making it readable once the delay tail and reverb arrive. If the source is already full-range, the intro will eat up headroom and blur the eventual drop transition.

    A versus B decision point:

    - A: darker and deeper — keep more of the low-mid body, but still cut below the sub zone. This suits grim, weighty rollers and steppy intros.

    - B: thinner and more skeletal — cut more aggressively and let the echo/reverb supply the body. This suits cleaner neuro intros where the atmosphere should feel hollow and distant.

    Choose A if the intro needs menace and mass. Choose B if the drop will already be very dense and you want the intro to stay more open.

    3. Build the Concrete Echo chain with Delay and Echo in a controlled order

    Use a return track or an audio track insert chain depending on how committed you want the sound to be. For a practical DnB intro, a track insert is often faster to shape, then you can print it later.

    A solid stock chain is:

    - Echo

    - Saturator

    - Reverb

    Or, if you want tighter control first:

    - Delay

    - EQ Eight

    - Echo

    - Saturator

    Suggested Echo starting points:

    - time synced to 1/8, 1/4, or dotted 1/8

    - feedback around 25–55%

    - filter the repeats so the tail is darker than the source

    - keep the stereo width moderate at first, then widen only if the mono balance stays clean

    Suggested Reverb starting points:

    - decay around 1.2–3.5 seconds

    - pre-delay around 10–30 ms

    - low cut fairly high so the reverb doesn’t cloud the bass later

    - high cut enough to stop the tail from fizzing

    Why this works in DnB: echo gives the intro a tempo-linked pulse, which is critical in drum and bass because even atmospheres need to feel like they belong to the grid. The delay creates motion; the reverb gives scale. Together, they make the space feel engineered rather than accidental.

    4. Filter the repeats, not just the dry sound

    A common mistake is shaping the original hit and forgetting the echoes. In a Concrete Echo intro, the repeats are the main event.

    In Echo, use the filter section to darken the tail:

    - low-pass the repeats so they sit roughly in the 1–6 kHz zone depending on brightness

    - if the tail is too fizzy, reduce the top end before it smears

    - if the tail is too muddy, trim the low-mid area after Echo with EQ Eight

    If you use Auto Filter before the delay, automate the cutoff slowly across 8 bars. That creates the feeling of a corridor opening up.

    What to listen for: the repeats should sound like they are bouncing off concrete, not like a shiny digital delay line. If you hear glassy brightness, the space is too polite for darkside DnB.

    5. Add controlled grit with Saturator or Drum Buss

    After the echo/reverb stage, add Saturator or Drum Buss to introduce density and a rougher surface. This is where the “concrete” part becomes physical.

    Practical starting points:

    - Saturator drive around 2–8 dB

    - use soft clipping or a gentle curve rather than aggressive destruction

    - if using Drum Buss, keep the boom low or off unless you specifically want a weighty low resonance

    - add just enough drive for the echoes to feel like they’re being pressed through a worn speaker or tunnel system

    Why this works: dark DnB atmospheres often need midrange harmonia so they read on club systems. Pure reverb can disappear. A little saturation makes the texture audible without needing volume.

    Fix-it moment: if the chain starts sounding crunchy in a bad way, reduce the echo feedback before reducing saturation. Too much feedback is often the real problem; saturation just exposes it.

    6. Make the texture rhythmic with clip editing or envelope automation

    Don’t let the intro drone endlessly. Give it a simple pattern that feels like it is breathing with the tune.

    Two practical ways in Ableton:

    - Edit the clip so the source hits appear on off-beats or irregular gaps

    - Automate the track gain, filter cutoff, or send level to create rise-and-fall motion over 4 or 8 bars

    A strong darkside pattern might be:

    - a hit on bar 1

    - a quieter echo response on the “and” of 2

    - a second hit or reversed version on bar 3

    - a denser tail into bar 4 as a lead-in

    For a more aggressive feel, use the echoes like a question-and-answer between empty space and impact. For a more cinematic feel, let one hit bloom and gradually become a wash.

    What to listen for: the pattern should create forward motion without sounding like a drum loop. If it starts competing with the actual drum groove you’ll add later, simplify it.

    7. Check the idea against the future drums and bass, not in isolation

    This is where the intro becomes real DnB instead of a sound-design sketch. Drop in your kick/snare pattern or a rough bass placeholder and check the atmospheric stretch in context.

    Listen for:

    - does the intro leave a clear lane for the snare crack?

    - does it avoid masking the sub region?

    - does the groove of the echo support the future break or clash with it?

    A useful test is to place a 1-bar or 2-bar drum loop under the atmosphere and mute/unmute the texture. The intro should feel like it belongs to the same record, not like an unrelated layer pasted on top.

    If the drums disappear, lower the atmosphere by a few dB, narrow it, or high-pass more aggressively. If the intro feels empty, add a second texture layer rather than just making the first one louder.

    8. Create a second layer through resampling for depth and realism

    Once the first chain feels good, resample or freeze/bounce the processed texture into a new audio track. This is a major efficiency move in Ableton because it turns a controllable but CPU-heavy process into audio you can sculpt faster.

    After resampling, cut and warp the new audio to find the best moments:

    - reverse a fragment for a pull-in

    - chop a tail and place it before the main hit

    - fade edges so the transitions feel natural

    - automate start position if you want small micro-variations

    Add a second stock-device chain to the resampled layer:

    - Auto Filter

    - Redux very lightly if you want degraded grit

    - Utility to narrow or widen the layer deliberately

    Keep the resampled layer lower than the original. Its job is to add weight and realism, not to dominate.

    Stop here if the resampled version already delivers the mood and the automation feels manageable. Commit this to audio if you want to move faster and avoid endless tweaking.

    9. Shape the intro as a phrase, not a loop

    Make the atmosphere follow a clear intro arc. In DnB, phrase clarity matters because DJs and listeners need to feel where the drop is coming from.

    A strong 8-bar structure could be:

    - bars 1–2: sparse, distant echo hits

    - bars 3–4: slightly more repeated motion and widening

    - bars 5–6: stronger filtering open or added texture layer

    - bars 7–8: tension peak, then a clean gap before the drum entry

    If you’re doing a 16-bar intro, repeat the idea with a subtle evolution:

    - second 8 bars should be more intense, slightly wider, or more degraded

    - avoid simply copying the first 8 bars at the same intensity

    This is where the intro becomes DJ-friendly. The listener should feel a clear ramp toward the drop, not a static loop that goes nowhere.

    10. Make sure the low end stays out of the way and the image stays club-safe

    Use Utility and EQ to keep the atmosphere out of the critical zones.

    Practical checks:

    - high-pass the atmosphere if it has any unnecessary low content

    - keep heavy stereo below control; the intro can be wide, but the low end should stay stable

    - if you have a subbed drone, verify it in mono and compare it to the full stereo version

    - use Utility’s width control carefully so the atmosphere doesn’t vanish or phase out

    What to listen for: in mono, the echo should still feel present, even if it becomes narrower. If it collapses into nothing, the stereo treatment is too dependent on phase tricks.

    A good rule: the intro can be spacious, but the feeling of pressure should remain centered. That way, when the kick and sub enter, the track doesn’t suddenly feel like it changed genre.

    Common Mistakes

    1. Making the atmosphere too full-range

    - Why it hurts: it masks the snare crack and muddies the eventual bass entrance.

    - Ableton fix: high-pass with EQ Eight and reduce low-mid buildup around 200–500 Hz.

    2. Using too much Echo feedback

    - Why it hurts: the tail turns into a foggy wash and stops feeling rhythmic.

    - Ableton fix: lower feedback, shorten decay in Echo or Reverb, and print only the best tail.

    3. Leaving the repeats too bright

    - Why it hurts: the intro feels shiny and synthetic instead of dark and concrete.

    - Ableton fix: use the Echo filter or an Auto Filter after the delay; tame top end before it hits reverb.

    4. Adding heavy stereo too early

    - Why it hurts: the atmosphere can sound impressive in headphones but unstable in mono and weak on club systems.

    - Ableton fix: use Utility to reduce width on the lowest parts of the layer, and check mono regularly.

    5. Not checking the intro against drums

    - Why it hurts: the texture may be fine alone but blocks the snare or obscures groove in context.

    - Ableton fix: audition the atmosphere with a rough kick/snare loop and pull it back until the drums stay dominant.

    6. Over-automating everything

    - Why it hurts: constant movement becomes distracting and kills the sense of space.

    - Ableton fix: automate just one or two key parameters over each phrase, like filter cutoff or send level.

    7. Keeping the loop static for too long

    - Why it hurts: dark intros need progression or they feel unfinished.

    - Ableton fix: introduce a second layer, reverse a tail, or widen the texture in the second 8 bars.

    Pro Tips for Darker / Heavier DnB

  • Print the echo tail and edit it like percussion. Once the atmosphere is bounced to audio, you can cut tiny gaps into it so the tail breathes around the groove. This often makes the intro feel more intentional than endless automation.

  • Use a filtered duplicate for depth. Keep one version darker and narrower, and another version wider but quieter. The darker layer gives body; the wider layer gives scale. This is a strong way to build menace without clutter.

  • Let the intro imply the drum pocket. If your future snare lands hard on 2 and 4, place atmospheric responses just after those hits or in the spaces between. That reinforces the groove instead of fighting it.

  • Distort the repeats more than the source. The dry hit should stay identifiable. The echoes can take more abuse. That separation preserves impact while still giving you grime.

  • Use slight timing nudges on resampled fragments. A few milliseconds early or late can make a metallic reflection feel like it’s bouncing in a real room. Don’t randomize blindly; place the off-grid elements where they support the phrase.

  • Keep one element deliberately narrow. A mono-ish concrete ping or low-mid drone can anchor the atmosphere and prevent the whole intro from becoming a wide haze.

  • If the track is very heavy, make the intro more empty than you think. Dark DnB often hits harder when the opening is restrained. The echo feels bigger because the arrangement gives it room.

    • Mini Practice Exercise

    Goal: Build a 16-bar Concrete Echo intro that can sit before a dark DnB drop.

    Time box: 15 minutes

    Constraints:

  • use only Ableton stock devices
  • start from one short source sound
  • use no more than three processing devices on the main chain
  • keep the low end out of the atmosphere
  • include at least one automation move and one resampled layer

    • Deliverable:

  • a 16-bar intro loop with a clear rise in tension
  • one printed audio layer
  • one check against a rough drum loop or bass placeholder

    • Quick self-check:

  • Can you hear the intro’s rhythm without the drums?
  • In mono, does the texture still feel present?
  • Does it leave space for a snare and sub to enter cleanly?
  • Does bar 15–16 create enough expectation for the drop?

    • Recap

    Concrete Echo in dark DnB is about turning a small impact into a tempo-locked atmosphere.

    Remember the core moves:

  • start with a hard, short source
  • shape the tone before you add space
  • use Echo + Reverb + Saturation to create the concrete feel
  • keep the repeats darker than the source
  • check the atmosphere against drums and bass early
  • evolve the intro in phrases, not just loops
  • protect mono compatibility and low-end space

If it feels like a cold, engineered space that is pulling the listener toward the drop without crowding the groove, you’re in the right zone.

Ask GPT about this lesson

Chat with the lesson tutor, get follow-up help, or use quick actions.

Bigup 👽 Ask me anything about this lesson and I’ll answer in context.

Narration script

Show spoken script 
Welcome back to DNB COLLEGE.

Today we’re building what I call a Concrete Echo intro stretch in Ableton Live 12. This is an intermediate darkside atmosphere move, and the goal is simple: make the opening of your tune feel cold, engineered, and heavy, like it’s echoing through a concrete corridor before the drums and bass fully arrive.

This kind of intro usually lives in the first 8 to 16 bars, or it works as a pre-drop tunnel for DJs. And that matters, because a good DnB intro is not just decoration. It sets the emotional world of the track. It tells the listener what kind of room they’re in before the groove lands. You want pressure, distance, and motion, but you still need enough space left for the kick, snare, and sub when they come in.

The lane for this is darkside, rollers, neuro-leaning, half-step tension, and more industrial DnB intros. If you want the tune to feel like it’s coming out of an abandoned rail yard, a warehouse stairwell, or a tunnel with no daylight, this is the technique.

Start with a dry source that has attitude. Not a pretty pad. Not a big lush chord. You want something with a hard edge. A metal hit, a scraped texture, a reverse reese stab, a found sound, or even a tiny transient pulled from a drum loop will do the job. If you want to synthesize it, use Operator or Wavetable and make a short tonal ping with a fast attack and a short decay.

Keep the source simple. No sustain. No long tail. No sub energy. Just a clean hit in the midrange with a bit of character. If you’re using a sample, trim the front edge so it’s tight. What you’re listening for here is impact. Even dry, it should feel like a wall strike or a mechanical object, not a musical wash.

Why this works in DnB is because the intro needs a recognisable echo source. Once delay and reverb start working, a hard source still reads clearly. A soft source often melts into fog too fast and loses that concrete identity.

Before you add any space, shape the source with EQ Eight. High-pass it somewhere around 150 to 300 Hz depending on the material. If it gets boxy, dip the 250 to 500 Hz range a little. If there’s harsh metallic bite, take a small cut around 3 to 6 kHz. And if it needs a bit more presence, a controlled lift around 1.5 to 3 kHz can help.

This is not about polishing it into something beautiful. It’s about making sure the hit still reads clearly once the echo tail and reverb arrive. If the source is too full-range, it will steal headroom and blur the eventual drop transition.

Now, there’s a useful creative decision here. You can go darker and deeper, keeping a bit more low-mid body while still cutting below the sub zone. That’s great for grim rollers and weighty steppy intros. Or you can go thinner and more skeletal, cutting more aggressively and letting the echo and reverb provide the body. That suits cleaner neuro intros where you want the atmosphere to feel hollow and distant. If the track is meant to feel massive and menacing, lean darker. If the drop is already dense and you want the intro to stay open, go thinner.

Now build the Concrete Echo chain. You can do this on an insert, or on a return if you want more shared control. For speed, I usually like it as an insert first, then you can print it later if needed.

A strong stock chain would be Echo, Saturator, and Reverb. Another good option is Delay, EQ Eight, Echo, and then Saturator if you want more control before the space gets huge.

Start with Echo. Sync it to something like one eighth, one quarter, or dotted one eighth. Put the feedback somewhere in the 25 to 55 percent range. Darken the repeats so the tail is clearly darker than the source. Keep the stereo width moderate at first. You can always open it up later if the mono balance stays healthy.

Then add Reverb, but keep it controlled. A decay around 1.2 to 3.5 seconds is a good starting point. Give it a bit of pre-delay, maybe 10 to 30 milliseconds, so the hit keeps its front edge. High-pass the reverb so it doesn’t cloud the bass later, and tame the top end if the tail starts to fizz.

What’s happening musically is that Echo gives you a tempo-linked pulse, and Reverb gives you scale. That combination is huge in DnB because even atmosphere needs to feel locked to the grid. You’re not making random ambience. You’re building engineered space.

One thing people often miss is this: filter the repeats, not just the dry source. The repeats are the real event here. In Echo, use the filter section to darken the tail. You want the reflections to sit somewhere in that 1 to 6 kHz zone depending on brightness, and if they get fizzy, remove the top end before it smears into the reverb. If the tail is muddy, clean it up after Echo with EQ Eight.

A great move is to put Auto Filter before the delay and slowly automate the cutoff over 8 bars. That gives the feeling of a corridor opening up. It’s subtle, but it changes the entire emotional arc.

What to listen for here is whether the repeats feel like they’re bouncing off concrete, or whether they sound like a shiny digital delay line. If it sounds too glossy, darken it. This style needs pressure, not polish.

After that, add a little grit. Saturator is perfect, and Drum Buss can also work if you want a tougher surface. Keep the drive moderate, maybe 2 to 8 dB, and use soft clipping or a gentle curve rather than going full destruction mode. If you use Drum Buss, be careful with the boom unless you specifically want a low resonance. The point is to make the echoes feel like they’re being pushed through a worn speaker or tunnel system.

And here’s a useful fix-it idea: if the chain starts sounding crunchy in a bad way, lower the feedback before you lower the saturation. A lot of the time, too much feedback is the real problem, and saturation just reveals it.

Now make it feel rhythmic. Don’t let it drone forever. You want it to breathe with the tune. In Ableton, you can do that by editing the clip so hits land on off-beats or irregular gaps, or by automating track gain, filter cutoff, or send level over 4 or 8 bars.

A nice darkside pattern could be a hit on bar one, a quieter echo answer on the and of two, another hit or reverse version on bar three, and then a thicker tail into bar four as the lead-in. For a more aggressive feel, make the atmosphere answer itself like a question and response between empty space and impact. For something more cinematic, let one hit bloom and gradually become a wash.

What to listen for is forward motion. It should move like a phrase, not like a drum loop. If it starts competing with the actual groove you plan to bring in later, simplify it. In dark DnB, space is part of the groove. If everything is always moving, the corridor disappears.

Now check the atmosphere against a rough kick and snare or a bass placeholder. This part is crucial. A texture can sound amazing on its own and still ruin the arrangement. Put a basic drum loop underneath and listen carefully. Does the intro leave a clear lane for the snare crack? Does it stay out of the sub zone? Does the echo rhythm support the future groove, or does it fight it?

If the drums disappear, lower the atmosphere a few dB, narrow it a bit, or high-pass it more aggressively. If the intro feels too empty, add a second texture layer instead of just turning up the first one. That keeps the arrangement cleaner.

At this point, resample or freeze and bounce the processed texture onto a new audio track. This is one of the best Ableton moves here because it turns a heavy process chain into audio you can cut and shape faster. Once it’s printed, you can reverse a fragment, chop a tail, fade edges, or shift tiny sections around to create micro-variation.

You can also add a second light chain to the resampled layer. Auto Filter is great here. Redux can add a bit of degraded grit if you want it. Utility can help you narrow or widen the layer on purpose. Keep this resampled version lower than the original. Its job is to add realism and weight, not to dominate the whole mix.

If the resampled version already sounds right, stop there. Seriously, don’t overcook it. Commit to audio and move into arrangement. That’s often the fastest way to keep the tune moving.

Now shape the intro as a phrase, not just a loop. A strong 8-bar version might start sparse, then gradually get more active and wider, and then finish with a clean little gap before the drums enter. If you’re doing 16 bars, the second half should evolve. Add a new layer, open the filter more, or make the echoes more damaged. Don’t just copy the first half louder.

This is what makes the intro DJ-friendly. The listener needs to feel the ramp. They need to sense that something is coming, not just hear a static texture that goes nowhere.

Keep an eye on low-end and stereo width. High-pass any unnecessary low content. Be careful with heavy stereo on the low end. The atmosphere can be wide, but the pressure should stay centered. Use Utility carefully, and check mono regularly. If the texture collapses completely in mono, it’s too dependent on phase tricks.

What to listen for in mono is whether the echo still feels present. It can get narrower, but it should not vanish. A good intro can be spacious without losing its core.

A few common mistakes are worth avoiding. Don’t make the atmosphere too full-range, because it will mask the snare and muddy the bass entrance. Don’t use too much feedback, because then the tail stops feeling rhythmic and turns into fog. Don’t leave the repeats too bright, or the intro starts sounding shiny instead of dark. Don’t throw heavy stereo on too early, and don’t forget to test it with drums. The solo version can fool you.

A really strong pro move is to print the echo tail and edit it like percussion. Cut tiny gaps into it so the tail breathes around the groove. You can also use a filtered duplicate, where one layer is darker and narrower, and another is wider but quieter. That gives you body and scale without clutter. And if the future snare is meant to hit hard on two and four, place the atmospheric responses just after those moments so the intro already feels connected to the drum pocket.

If you want even more menace, distort the repeats more than the source. Keep the dry hit identifiable and roughen the space around it. That separation keeps the impact intact while still giving you grime. Small timing nudges on resampled fragments can also make the reflections feel more real, like they’re bouncing in an actual room instead of floating in a plugin.

Here’s the bigger mindset shift: treat this like a pre-drop system, not a standalone sound design loop. If it doesn’t make the next section hit harder, it’s not finished. That’s the real DnB test.

So, to recap, you start with a short, hard source. You clean the tone before adding space. You build the Concrete Echo character with Echo, Reverb, and a bit of Saturator. You darken the repeats, keep the low end under control, and check everything against a rough drum loop early. Then you resample, edit the audio, and shape the intro as a phrase with a clear rise in tension. Keep it cold, keep it engineered, and leave room for the drop.

Now I want you to try the 16-bar exercise. Use only Ableton stock devices, start from one short source sound, keep the low end out of the atmosphere, and include at least one automation move and one resampled layer. Then test it against a kick, snare, or bass placeholder. If you want to push yourself, build both versions: one more threatening and narrow, and one more cinematic and wide. Compare them in mono, and ask which one leaves more room for the snare and sub, and which one makes the drop feel more inevitable.

That’s the move. Build the corridor, control the reflections, and let the listener feel the pressure before the groove lands.

mickeybeam

Go to drumbasscd.com for +100 drum and bass YouTube channels all in one place - tune in!

Generating PDF preview…